People talk
Our Guestbook
“ This place is a hidden gem! We stopped in for dinner. The place was packed as it was homecoming or something at the local university. We got subs. First of all everything was fresh and made with care. The bread was amazing. I asked the owner if they made the bread in- house. They do, and in my opinion, those are the best sub rolls I've ever had. They were huge too! I had a cheesesteak. The meat was fresh and tender and not your typical frozen "steak um" meat. The veggies were fresh and crisp. The owner had a long day but still took the time to talk with us and shared stories as it was the end of the night, and they were closing up. Thank you! ”
“ What an unexpectedly delicious meal I stumbled upon tonight! The pies are top notch; and the fries?! The real stuff! Will definitely be back soon. ”
“ This place is amazing! Food is great and customer service is excellent. They’re so nice. Highly recommend for Lewisburg pizza! ”
“ Check out this unassuming little restaurant on Market St. There aren't a ton of notable restaurants in the Lewisburg area, esp walking distance from downtown. Usually, at most places, when you get a sub, the bread is either too hard or too small so it falls apart or the contents shoot out when you take a bite. The bread at Pi Pizza is baked fresh daily. I don't know if they advertise it, but they really should. It's great. It does not get soggy but yet is both soft, flavorful, and substantial. It actually covers all the contents. This is real man's sandwich. :). You really got to try it! (I usually get an Italian sub.) ”
“ Absolutely love the food here! Their cheese pizzas are delicious and the appetizer's are incredible. We usually get the deep fried pizza rolls and they are perfect every time. The staff is cool and great too! Love ordering lunch from here. ”
“ Fast friendly service. This is my best friend’s favorite pizza spot in town. She likes a thinner crust. Dough was fresh and we like the tomatoes. Custom orders available. Pizza can be ready usually within 15 minutes. It’s place you can place an order and wait for them to make it. It’s nice to have another great spot to grab a slice downtown. ”
“ Wanted to try the new Pi Pizza establishment and felt like getting something different. I decided on the large taco pizza and was not disappointed. Very tasty and flavorful. I finished all but two pieces in one sitting. Got up in the middle of the night for a couple bites from one of the two pieces in the fridge then ate the rest cold for breakfast. Also want to mention how friendly the staff were when picking up the pizza. ”
“ Definitely stop in if you haven't had Pi Pizza! Everything is made with fresh ingredients and from scratch. The wrap was delicious. Cheesesteak and fries are the best around. Will stop in time and time again :) ”
Menu
Cheese Pi
US$16.00Chicken Fingers
US$8.00Salad Dressings
Greek Salad
US$10.00Ceasar Salad
US$10.00
About
Pi Pizza
Welcome to the culinary haven of Pi Pizza, located at 316 Market St, Lewisburg, PA. An unassuming gem in the heart of the university town, Pi Pizza has quickly garnered a reputation for its exceptional food and welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're stopping in for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, Pi Pizza is dedicated to providing a delightful dining experience.
As soon as you step inside, you're greeted by the rich aroma of fresh ingredients. Customers rave about their indulgent pies and generous sandwiches, especially the subs. A standout feature is the bread, which is made in-house and praised for its remarkable flavor and texture. With large, chewy rolls that hold a bounty of fresh, tender fillings without falling apart, it's no wonder patrons describe them as "the best sub rolls I've ever had." It’s the kind of bread that makes each bite a joy, elevating the simple sandwich into a meal to remember.
Reviewers like Tim Grant and Joshua Blum highlight the thoughtful preparation and care that goes into each dish. Tim's cheesesteak featured quality, fresh meat unlike the standard offerings from lesser establishments, while Joshua champions the daily-baked bread that enhances the overall experience. It’s evident that the kitchen at Pi Pizza takes pride in crafting every dish, from subs to sides.
And what’s not to love about their pizzas? Nicole Oliver describes them as "top notch," complementing them with a hearty serving of fries that she calls "the real stuff." This attention to detail extends beyond the food; Kenroy Hensley finds the customer service equally impressive, noting the friendly demeanor of the staff, making every visit feel like a warm interaction with friends.
Further enhancing the menu are special appetizers like deep-fried pizza rolls, which Jessica Sorokach claims are "perfect every time." These unique dishes reflect the innovative spirit of Pi Pizza while honoring the classic comforts we all crave. Each meal is not just about sustenance—it's an experience marinated in flavor and warmth.
So next time you're in Lewsburg, whether for homecoming festivities or a casual evening, don’t miss out on Pi Pizza. With its outstanding food and inviting atmosphere, it’s a destination that delivers hospitality and flavor in every bite. It’s more than just a meal; it’s an invitation to come back again and again.
Book a table